Fantasy Island returns for Season 2 January 2, 2023 on Fox. Season 2 Episode 3 is titled “Paymer vs. Paymer” Here is the synopsis from TV Guide: “Empty nesters Dolly and Dutch seek clarity on how to spend their next chapter; … Continue reading #FantasyIsland Paymer vs. Palmer S2Ep3 Preview via @stacyamiller85 @FantasyIslandTV