Roasted Thanksgiving turkey on a platter, ready for a family holiday meal.

Why Does Thanksgiving Either Get Ignored Completely or Turned Into a Murder?

Can somebody please explain to me what Hollywood has against Thanksgiving?

Seriously! Halloween gets an entire month of horror movies, Christmas gets approximately 4,000 movies a year, and Thanksgiving? Well, apparently we either get a dysfunctional family screaming at each other across the dinner table or somebody getting murdered before the turkey even makes it out of the oven.

What in the hell, Hollyweird?

I understand Thanksgiving doesn’t exactly lend itself to the same kind of storytelling as Halloween or Christmas, but surely we can do better than pretending the holiday doesn’t exist until somebody decides to make a horror movie about it.

And don’t even get me started on how Christmas seems to begin the second Halloween ends. Poor Thanksgiving doesn’t even get a chance!

Now, before we get into the movies, I want to make something clear. I’m not a fan of the romanticized Thanksgiving story we were taught growing up. What happened to Indigenous peoples was an atrocity, and I’m not interested in pretending otherwise.

But Thanksgiving has a different meaning for me today.

It’s about family and friends coming together and celebrating everything that makes us a family. The good, the bad, and everything in between. Nobody has to be perfect. Life doesn’t have to have been wonderful all year. We can still come together, enjoy each other’s company, and appreciate the people who make our lives what they are.

And honestly, Hollywood has given us a few movies that capture that pretty well.

Unfortunately, they’ve also given us a turkey-themed body count.

Son in Law Is Thanksgiving Perfection, and I Will Hear No Arguments

If there’s one Thanksgiving movie I absolutely love, it’s Son in Law (1993).

This movie gets watched in my house at least once a year. AT LEAST.

And honestly, what’s not to love?

Pauly Shore as Crawl, Carla Gugino as Rebecca, and a supporting cast that makes this movie even better.

First of all, can we talk about how amazing ’90s Pauly Shore was? Because I don’t care what anybody says, that man was amazeballs!

Encino Man, Son in Law, In the Army Now. He had an entire era of ridiculous comedy, and I loved it.

And Crawl? That character was something else.

“Greeeeen Acres is the place to be!” 🎶

Here’s this California college guy showing up at Rebecca’s family’s farm, looking completely out of place, and somehow managing to become exactly what this family didn’t know it needed.

He’s hilarious, but he’s also surprisingly intelligent. Remember when he shows off his computer skills? The guy isn’t nearly as clueless as everyone assumes.

And he connects with Rebecca’s little brother, played by PATRICK FREAKING RENNA!!

Yes, THAT Patrick Renna.

Her dad was freaking awesome, Grandpa was a G, and Mom was a fox. Seriously, I loved that family.

And then there’s Rebecca’s boyfriend, Travis. That man had trouble written all over his sexy face. You could just tell!

Oh, and let’s not forget Tiffani Thiessen!

This movie is practically a little time capsule of everything I loved about ’90s entertainment.

But underneath all the ridiculous comedy, there’s something genuinely sweet about Son in Law. Crawl doesn’t fit into Rebecca’s family’s world at first. He’s different from everyone around him, and nobody quite knows what to make of him. But eventually, they begin seeing him for who he really is.

And he becomes part of their family.

THAT is the kind of Thanksgiving movie I love.

Funny, ridiculous, full of memorable characters, and ultimately about accepting people for who they are.

Plus, Pauly Shore. I mean, come on!

Apparently Thanksgiving Also Means Family Drama

Now, I know Son in Law isn’t the only Thanksgiving movie out there.

We’ve also got Planes, Trains and Automobiles (1987), which gives us Steve Martin and John Candy trying to get home for Thanksgiving. And honestly, putting those two together was already a pretty brilliant idea.

Then there’s Home for the Holidays (1995), directed by Jodie Foster, with Holly Hunter, Robert Downey Jr., Anne Bancroft, and Charles Durning.

I’ve seen this one, although it’s been a while, so I’m not going to pretend I remember every little detail.

But it’s another example of Hollywood’s favorite Thanksgiving tradition: getting a bunch of relatives together and letting the dysfunction begin.

And you know what? I don’t necessarily have a problem with that.

Families are complicated. People argue. Somebody inevitably says something they probably should’ve kept to themselves. Not everybody gets along all the time.

That’s life.

We don’t have to pretend everybody gets along perfectly to appreciate the people in our lives. Although, if Hollywood could occasionally let a family finish Thanksgiving dinner without some kind of emotional catastrophe, that would be nice.

And Then There’s the Murder

Of course, apparently somebody in Hollywood looked at Thanksgiving and thought, “You know what this holiday needs? More blood.”

Enter Thanksgiving (2023), directed by Eli Roth.

Because why not?

We’ve already got Halloween covered when it comes to horror. Christmas has plenty of killer Santas and other holiday nightmares. Apparently, Thanksgiving needed to get in on the action, too.

And I understand the appeal. Horror movies built around holidays have been around forever, and I’m certainly no stranger to enjoying a good slasher.

But it does make me laugh that Thanksgiving has so few movies dedicated to it, and one of the more recent high-profile additions involves people getting murdered.

Really, Hollywood?

We couldn’t get another ridiculous family comedy first?

We had to go straight to the carving?

I suppose it makes sense in a twisted sort of way. Between the family drama, holiday shopping madness, and everyone trying to put together the perfect dinner, Thanksgiving probably gives horror writers plenty to work with.

Still, I’d love to see more movies that celebrate the holiday without requiring a body count.

Can Thanksgiving Have Its Own Moment?

Here’s what gets me.

Halloween has barely ended before we’re surrounded by Christmas decorations, Christmas music, Christmas movies, and approximately a thousand different versions of somebody discovering the true meaning of Christmas.

Meanwhile, Thanksgiving is standing somewhere in the middle going, “Hello? Remember me?”

And I think that’s a shame.

Not because I want Hollywood to start pumping out dozens of terrible Thanksgiving movies every year. Believe me, we have enough terrible holiday movies already.

But because there’s something special about the kind of stories Thanksgiving can tell.

Family. Friendship. Forgiveness. People who don’t necessarily belong together finding common ground. People realizing that what they have might be worth more than what they’ve spent their lives chasing.

And sometimes it’s simply about sitting around a table with the people you love, laughing about something completely ridiculous.

That’s the Thanksgiving I appreciate.

Not the sanitized history lesson, and certainly not the idea that every family has to look or behave a certain way.

Just people coming together and appreciating what makes them a family.

And if that family happens to include Pauly Shore singing about Green Acres, a young Patrick Renna, and Grandpa being an absolute legend?

Even better.

So, Hollywood, how about showing Thanksgiving a little more love?

Give us more comedies. Give us more heartfelt stories. Give us families who are messy, funny, ridiculous, and still manage to love each other.

And sure, throw in the occasional Thanksgiving horror movie. I’m not saying we have to get rid of those.

I’m just saying it’d be nice if somebody could make it through dinner without getting murdered.

Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’ve got a date with Son in Law.

“Greeeeen Acres is the place to be!” 🎶

Leave a Reply