Some movies stay with you because they’re brilliant.
Some stay with you because they changed cinema.
And then there are movies like The Cowboy Way, where more than 30 years later I’m still sitting here thinking about Woody Harrelson telling a waiter how he wants his steak cooked.
If you’ve seen this movie, you already know EXACTLY where I’m going.
“Knock its horns off, wipe its nasty ass…”
Yep. That one.
I remembered that freaking line all these years later. And because apparently my brain has decided this is important information worth preserving forever, I went back and checked to see how close my memory actually was.
Pretty damn close. The full line is even better than I remembered.
And honestly, that pretty much sums up my relationship with The Cowboy Way.
Was this one of the greatest movies of 1994?
Absolutely not.
Did the critics love it?
Oh HELL no.
Do I care?
Also no.
Because The Cowboy Way was fun. Kiefer Sutherland and Woody Harrelson had fantastic chemistry, the movie had some epic lines, and underneath all the cowboy-meets-New-York craziness was actually a story about friendship, loyalty and two guys willing to travel across the country because somebody they cared about needed them.
And apparently I have been waiting 32 years to defend this freaking movie.
First of All, Kiefer and Woody
Whoever decided to put Kiefer Sutherland and Woody Harrelson together deserves some credit here.
Sutherland plays Sonny Gilstrap, the more serious, levelheaded half of the pair. Harrelson plays Pepper Lewis, who is basically what would happen if somebody put a cowboy hat on chaos and gave it tequila.
They shouldn’t work as well together as they do.
But they freaking do.
There is something you need to understand about me and Kiefer Sutherland.
Eye for an Eye kind of ruined this man for me. 😂
I had already seen and loved The Cowboy Way and The Lost Boys before I ever watched Kiefer play Robert Doob. Then I saw Eye for an Eye and apparently my brain decided, “Well, that’s Kiefer now.”
I can still watch Eye for an Eye, but I cringe through the entire freaking movie. Robert Doob freaks me out that much. And honestly, that’s probably one of the biggest compliments I can give Kiefer Sutherland as an actor. He made that man so disturbing that decades later I still have trouble looking at Kiefer without some little part of my brain remembering Doob.
Somehow Sonny Gilstrap escaped that fate. I loved Sonny before I met Robert Doob, and apparently that matters. 😂 I can still watch The Cowboy Way and see the cowboy I loved instead of the character who would later make my skin crawl.
Sonny and Pepper are lifelong friends and rodeo partners who aren’t exactly getting along when the movie begins. Pepper failed to show up for an important rodeo, Sonny is still pissed about it, and the two spend a good chunk of the movie bickering like people who know exactly which buttons to push because they’ve been pushing them their entire lives.
A contemporary Deseret News review actually complained about all that bickering.
That’s part of why I buy them as friends.
They’re not two random action heroes who meet five minutes before the plot starts and magically become buddies. These two have HISTORY. They’re mad at each other. They know each other’s bullshit. They can irritate the hell out of each other.
And when something actually matters?
They’re there.
That’s friendship.
Also, it turns out at least some of that chemistry really was Kiefer and Woody. In a 1994 interview before the movie opened, Harrelson was asked how much of Pepper’s riffing and joking came from him. His answer was basically: a lot of it came from either him or Kiefer. He even explained that one of Pepper’s bar bits came from something that had actually happened to him in New York. So yes, some of that Sonny-and-Pepper energy really was the actors playing around with the material.
And you can feel it.
But This Wasn’t Just Two Cowboys Screwing Around in New York
This is the part of The Cowboy Way I think gets lost when people remember it as that goofy movie where Woody Harrelson and Kiefer Sutherland ride horses around New York City.
Because there’s actually a pretty dark reason they’re there.
Their friend and mentor, Nacho Salazar, goes to New York because he’s trying to bring his daughter Teresa to the United States from Cuba. When Nacho disappears, Sonny and Pepper leave New Mexico and go looking for him.
Then they discover Nacho has been killed.
Teresa is still being held by the people who smuggled her into the country, and suddenly this isn’t just about finding their friend anymore.
They have to find his daughter.
That’s actually the heart of the movie.
And maybe that’s one of the reasons I’ve always liked it.
Sonny and Pepper don’t have to do this.
Teresa isn’t their daughter. She’s not their sister. They’re not cops. Nobody hired them. There isn’t a giant reward waiting at the end.
She is Nacho’s daughter.
That’s enough.
Their friend died trying to get his child back, so they’re going to finish what he started.
That’s the cowboy way.
And yes, I realize how freaking cheesy that sounds.
I don’t care. 😂
These Guys Were COWBOYS
Here’s something else I miss about movies like this.
Sonny and Pepper weren’t cowboys because the movie slapped hats on Kiefer Sutherland and Woody Harrelson and called it a day.
These guys WORKED.
They were rodeo cowboys from New Mexico. The movie opens in that world. Riding, roping, competing, getting dirty, getting knocked around and doing the kind of physical work where your body is part of the job.
Even the contemporary critics who hated the movie described Sonny and Pepper as men who had grown up on the rodeo circuit, bucking broncs and roping calves.
And I freaking love that.
Because when we talk about “cowboy movies,” people immediately think Western.
Old West. Gunslingers. Horses tied outside a saloon.
The Cowboy Way wasn’t that.
This was 1994.
These were modern cowboys living in the same world everybody else was living in.
And Hollywood made a mainstream summer movie about them.
Actually, let me save that thought for another article, because I have some QUESTIONS about where the hell those movies went.
We’ll get there.
And Then These Cowboys Hit New York City
Obviously, this is where the movie has most of its fun.
Take two New Mexico rodeo cowboys and dump them into Manhattan.
What could possibly go wrong?
Everything.
They don’t suddenly change who they are because they’re in New York. They approach the city the same way they approach everything else.
Including dinner at the Waldorf Astoria.
The waiter asks how they’d like their steaks prepared.
Pepper has to clarify that by “prepared” he means cooked, because apparently we’re already off to a great start.
Then comes the line that has apparently rented permanent space in my brain since the ’90s:
“Just knock its horns off, wipe its nasty ass…”
I’m stopping there because if you want the rest, go enjoy Pepper’s full instructions yourself.
Then the waiter asks about wine.
Pepper orders “something or other.”
American.
Not too sweet.
And wants ice in it.
This poor freaking waiter. 😂
That’s the humor I remember from The Cowboy Way. It isn’t complicated. Nobody is pretending it is.
It’s two cowboys being completely, unapologetically themselves in a place where they stick out like somebody dropped a bull in Times Square.
Actually, considering this movie, I’m surprised they didn’t do that too.
Apparently the Critics and I Need to Have a Talk
Now here’s where things get funny.
I started looking at what critics actually said about The Cowboy Way when it came out.
WOW.
They did not like this freaking movie.
Kenneth Turan at the Los Angeles Times said Woody Harrelson was basically the only reason to sit through it, and even Woody wasn’t enough. That’s not exactly a pull quote Universal was slapping across the VHS box.
The Deseret News wasn’t any kinder, calling it another fish-out-of-water buddy movie and criticizing the story, characters and logic. They REALLY didn’t like it.
And you know what?
Fine.
They’re allowed to be wrong.
😂
I’m kidding.
Mostly.
Because here’s the thing: I’m not going to sit here in 2026 and tell you The Cowboy Way was secretly some cinematic masterpiece everybody was too stupid to understand.
It wasn’t.
The plot gets ridiculous. Some of the humor is very 1994. The entire premise requires you to accept that these two rodeo cowboys can show up in New York and cowboy their way through a criminal trafficking operation.
This is not The Godfather.
But sometimes I think we’ve gotten way too comfortable acting like every movie has to be IMPORTANT to be worth remembering.
Sometimes a movie can just be a damn good time.
And I had a damn good time with this one.
Maybe That’s Why I Still Remember It
Here’s what I remember about The Cowboy Way after all these years.
I remember laughing.
I remember the steak.
I remember Woody Harrelson being completely ridiculous.
I remember Kiefer Sutherland playing the straight man beside him and somehow making Woody even funnier because of it.
I remember the horses.
I remember the rodeo.
But more than anything, I remember Sonny and Pepper.
That’s chemistry.
And underneath all the jokes, those two represented something I think the movie actually understood pretty well about the cowboy image.
You work.
You show up.
You don’t abandon your people.
Nacho needed them, so they went looking for him.
When Nacho couldn’t save Teresa himself, they did it for him.
They could be pissed at each other and still have each other’s backs.
That’s not about boots or hats.
That’s character.
Hollywood, Can We Have These Guys Back?
Watching movies from this period now, something keeps jumping out at me.
Where the hell did the modern cowboy go?
Not the Western cowboy.
I know Hollywood still makes Westerns.
I’m talking about this guy.
The working cowboy.
The rodeo cowboy.
The guy who owns a truck instead of a stagecoach but can still rope a steer.
The cowboy who exists NOW.
Because The Cowboy Way came out on June 3, 1994. Universal put a contemporary cowboy buddy movie starring Kiefer Sutherland and Woody Harrelson into theaters as a summer release.
And just a few months earlier, Hollywood had released another movie about a modern rodeo cowboy.
8 Seconds.
Lane Frost.
Now THAT is a completely different movie and a completely different article.
And trust me, we’re going there next.
But I can’t ignore the fact that both movies came out in the same freaking year.
Two mainstream movies.
Two completely different tones.
Both centered around modern cowboy and rodeo culture.
Thirty-two years later, I’m sitting here wondering why that feels almost impossible now.
But that’s a question for another day.
For now, I’m going to give The Cowboy Way exactly what I think it deserves.
Not five stars.
Not an argument that the critics misunderstood some hidden artistic masterpiece.
Just a little freaking appreciation.
Because Kiefer Sutherland and Woody Harrelson made me believe Sonny and Pepper had been driving each other crazy their entire lives.
Because two cowboys crossed the country looking for their friend and stayed to save his daughter.
Because Hollywood gave us hardworking modern cowboys instead of pretending cowboys disappeared sometime around 1890.
And because more than three decades later, if a waiter asks me how I want my steak cooked, there’s still a tiny part of my brain that immediately thinks:
Knock its horns off.
Some movies win Oscars.
Some movies make history.
And some movies just stick around in your head for 32 freaking years.
I’ll take that too.
