Spoiler warning: This article contains major spoilers for Episodes 4, 5 and 6 of American Horror Story: 13.
I really thought after the first three episodes I had some idea of what American Horror Story: 13 was doing. I did not. Not even a little bit. Somewhere between working, life and finishing illustrations for my second children’s book, I finally got through Episodes 4, 5 and 6, and now I have even more questions than I did before. We got more Mr. Nas, more of Ben DeSoto’s very strange connection to the number 13, witches developing powers they shouldn’t have, returning characters everywhere, dead serial killers attacking the Coven and a cliffhanger that actually made me yell at my TV. So, yeah. They definitely pulled me back in.
Ben Is Getting More Suspicious by the Episode
Episode 4 picks up right where we left Ben, and Mr. Nas is still doing whatever the hell he’s doing with that black substance. He pulls Ben toward him, pours it into his mouth and then suddenly we’re looking at a younger version of Mr. Nas. And listen. Young Mr. Nas is hot. I’m sorry, he is.
Things only get weirder from there with Elsa Mars bringing back her Cabinet of Curiosities and the whole thing turning into Mr. Nas’s Jezebel Ball. Twelve women who were taken before reaching their full potential are brought out to be sacrificed, including familiar faces like Hypodermic Sally, Tuberculosis Karen and Elizabeth Short. Except somebody apparently can’t count because they only have twelve. Wilhemina Venable fixes that problem herself by becoming number thirteen and throwing herself into the pit.
Elsa being completely over the entire thing was probably one of my favorite parts. Everyone is taking this demonic ceremony very seriously while she’s basically wondering how many more women they’re going to drag out. I felt that.
The thirteen sacrifices raise Mr. Nas’s biomarkers to 96, just shy of 100, which apparently is where we need to get for whatever the hell is coming next. Then Constance Langdon and Mr. Phibes sit around playing cards and casually discuss all of this like they’re talking about the weather.
Phibes is becoming one of the strangest and funniest parts of this season. The man has three rules that include never refusing a rim job from a married man, never turning down a free drink and never cheating at cards. We also find out he sold his soul because he wanted to make a biker movie. Okay then.
Constance’s reason for making her own deal is much sadder. She wanted another chance at motherhood, and Mr. Nas gave it to her. But it’s something Phibes says afterward that really got my attention. He mentions Mr. Nas’s son drinking from the chalice.
Um. Didn’t we JUST watch Ben drink that black shit?
I’m not saying Ben is Mr. Nas’s son. Yet. But I’ve got my eye on him.
Episode 5 doesn’t exactly make Ben look any less suspicious either. Ashley, another survivor of the plane crash, comes to see him and we learn she was also friends with Kira. She tells Ben that Kira wasn’t necessarily the person he thought she was, and then we get more of Ashley’s own story, including why she also has triskaidekaphobia.
Then Ben starts talking about his past and holy shit, 13 has been following this man his entire life. He was born on Friday the 13th. His mother died giving birth to him. His father later died in a car accident. Ben went through six different sets of foster parents. Martha finally gave him a home, only to die on his 13th birthday. Kira eventually became the next person who made him feel like he had a home. And Kira died on Friday the 13th.
Then Ashley sees something on Ben’s lower back: 616. It’s a brand, not a tattoo, and Ben apparently didn’t even know it was there.
My brain immediately went: 6 + 1 + 6 = 13.
WHAT THE HELL?
Between that, the plane crash, everything surrounding his life and Phibes specifically talking about Mr. Nas’s son drinking from the chalice, I am becoming more and more convinced there is something much bigger going on with Ben.
Also, is it just me, or do these episodes feel especially short?
Madison Is Still Very Much Madison
Episode 6 is where things really go off the rails. It opens with Jeffrey Dahmer and James Patrick March from Hotel driving around in a self-driving car and talking about modern technology. Dahmer has apparently discovered just how easy phones, Grindr and text chains can make things, while March seems fascinated by all of it.
Their conversation gets even funnier when Dahmer basically asks why he’s become March’s secretary. March’s answer amounts to him always finding Dahmer boring, originally thinking he was insecure and eventually deciding maybe he’s just not that bright. Jesus Christ.
Then we’re back at Miss Robichaux’s Academy, where Morwenna suddenly demonstrates a pretty incredible power. She takes a dead frog and returns it to a living tadpole. Cordelia Goode wants to know exactly when and how the hell she learned to do that.
Morwenna says it only started two days ago. She felt tingling and something in her chest connecting to something warm and bright, and suddenly she just knew. Cordelia does not take this well.
The confrontation ends with Morwenna pinned to the damn ceiling, but Madison Montgomery is standing there being Madison through the entire thing. Her asking whether Morwenna was supposed to “resurrect your old cooch” because that thing definitely isn’t coming back to life was so completely on-brand that I lost it.
Emma Roberts is ridiculously good at this character. Madison always has some shit to say, no matter how serious the situation is, and I love it.
But Cordelia isn’t just being paranoid. Three girls have manifested new powers under the new moon—powers they should only see once in a generation. Queenie asks the obvious question: Why is that bad?
Because the magic knows something they don’t.
Now we’re getting somewhere.
Cordelia knows something is coming, but she can’t see it. Something seems to be concealing the threat from her, which means she has no idea how she’s supposed to protect the Coven. She starts questioning whether whatever is coming needs the kind of Supreme her mother Fiona Goode was—someone far more ruthless than Cordelia has ever wanted to be.
Queenie tries to remind her exactly who she is. She is Cordelia Goode. She is the Supreme. But Cordelia is scared, and for good reason.
Nothing a Coven of 13 Can’t Handle…Right?
Cordelia, Madison, Queenie, Coco and the rest of the witches gather together, drink absinthe and turn to the old ways to contact the dead. And there are 13 witches. Of course there are.
Someone even says there’s “nothing a coven of 13 can’t handle.” At this point, if somebody orders 13 chicken nuggets I’m going to assume it’s part of the plot.
They make contact the forgotten way, using a spirit board while combining their magic. A dead flower comes back to life, but initially nothing else seems to happen. Naturally, Madison decides this has all been a waste of time and announces that she’s going to watch porn and eat s’mores. Because, again, Madison.
And that’s when the little glass on the spirit board starts moving by itself.
H-E-R-E.
Cordelia sends everyone else away. She believes Fiona has answered her and that her mother is there specifically for her. She’s wrong.
Cordelia starts walking through Miss Robichaux’s looking for Fiona and instead finds James Patrick March. And everything goes to absolute shit.
March walks into the Academy carrying a sickle, and Cordelia basically mocks him for bringing a gardening tool to fight the Supreme. He throws it at her. She sends it right back into him. And the bastard keeps coming. Of course he does. He’s already dead.
Then suddenly the other Devil’s Night serial killers are inside Miss Robichaux’s too, and that funny opening scene with Dahmer and March isn’t funny anymore.
The text chain. The talk about getting everyone together. The “unsavories.” They were assembling. They came for the Coven.
Ophelia gets grabbed. The witches are under attack. Cordelia spent the entire episode knowing something terrible was coming but unable to see it, and now that threat has literally walked through her front door.
And then March kills Cordelia. Or at least that’s sure as hell what it looks like.
WHAT THE HELL?
That’s it. That’s where they leave us.
So now I have to wait until next week to find out whether Cordelia Goode is really dead and what happens to Madison, Queenie, Ophelia, Morwenna, Coco and the rest of the Coven.
But come on. There are 13 witches in that house. We have already watched these women do some ridiculously powerful shit, and now some of the younger witches are manifesting powers that should only appear once in a generation. You’re telling me there isn’t enough power between all of them to take down a house full of dead serial killers?
There better be.
Because after six episodes of 13 being shoved in my face from every possible direction, “nothing a coven of 13 can’t handle” better not have been famous last words.
And yes, obviously I’ll be back next week.
