I have a question. Where the hell did all the cowboys go?
And before somebody starts sending me a list of every Western released in the last twenty years, that’s not exactly what I mean. I know Hollywood still makes Westerns. We’ve had True Grit, Django Unchained, The Hateful Eight, The Revenant, Hell or High Water, The Power of the Dog and plenty more.
I’m talking about cowboy movies. The rodeo cowboy. The ranch cowboy. The funny cowboy. The romantic cowboy. The cowboy who could show up in a buddy comedy without the movie needing to take place in 1887. The guy who just happened to wear boots, ride horses and live that life because that’s who he was.
I swear those guys used to be all over the movies when I was growing up.
Of course, there’s one problem with relying on your own childhood memories: sometimes everything seemed bigger when you were a kid. Maybe there weren’t actually that many cowboy movies. Maybe I just happened to love them, so they’re the ones I remember. Maybe Hollywood didn’t change at all.
So I went looking.
Nope.
There were cowboys freaking everywhere.
Apparently, I Grew Up During a Cowboy Comeback
Here’s the part I didn’t know.
For decades, Westerns were one of Hollywood’s bread-and-butter genres. According to a history of the Hollywood Western from Cambridge University Press, Westerns accounted for roughly a quarter of American films during the 1940s and 1950s. By the 1980s, though, the genre had fallen a LONG way from that position. Cambridge University Press has a fascinating history of that rise and decline.
Then Kevin Costner came along.
Dances with Wolves arrived in 1990, made a ton of money and won Best Picture. Two years later, Clint Eastwood’s Unforgiven also won Best Picture. Suddenly Hollywood looked at a genre everybody had been treating like it was half-dead and apparently thought, Wait. Are cowboys cool again?
Yes. Yes, they were.
And that’s the funny part of this whole thing. I didn’t grow up during the tail end of some uninterrupted golden age of cowboy movies.
I grew up during their comeback.
No wonder I remember them being everywhere. They were.
1994 Called. It Has All Our Cowboys.
Okay, this is ridiculous.
Look at what was happening around 1993 and 1994: Tombstone. Geronimo. Maverick. Wyatt Earp. Bad Girls. City Slickers II. Lightning Jack. The Cowboy Way. 8 Seconds.
And that’s not me grabbing every movie where somebody walked within ten feet of a horse just to make my argument look better. Hollywood really had gone cowboy crazy.
The best part? People noticed it at the time. In July 1994, The Washington Post wrote about the cowboy suddenly seeming to be everywhere following the success of Dances with Wolves and Unforgiven, naming movie after movie from the new Western boom. You can read that 1994 piece here.
So this isn’t me sitting here at 44 years old creating a pattern out of the movies I loved when I was younger. People were looking around in 1994 and basically asking the same question in reverse:
Why are there cowboys everywhere?
Meanwhile, 32 years later, I’m over here like, CAN WE HAVE SOME BACK?
Also, Bad Girls.
Ohhhhh, Bad Girls.
Madeleine Stowe, Mary Stuart Masterson, Andie MacDowell and Drew Barrymore riding around the West together? Yes, please.
We’re coming back to that movie because it absolutely deserves its own article. For now, let’s just appreciate that Hollywood apparently looked at all the men riding around in 1994 and said, You know what? The women need horses too.
And I was here for it.
But Lane Frost Wasn’t Hollywood’s Cowboy
There is one movie in that 1994 group that I need to talk about differently.
8 Seconds brought Lane Frost’s story to movie audiences. Lane wasn’t a cowboy somebody in Hollywood created. He was a real cowboy. He was a professional bull rider, a world champion, a husband, a son and a friend. He lived that life.
Hollywood didn’t invent Lane Frost. We were lucky enough to have his story brought to the screen.
That’s important to me because I don’t want to toss Lane onto a list next to fictional characters and make it sound like everybody simply put on cowboy hats for 1994. Luke Perry portrayed Lane, but Lane’s life existed long before Hollywood came calling. Considering how many people discovered Lane through 8 Seconds—including me—I’m grateful his story was told.
Actually, 8 Seconds and The Cowboy Way are why I started thinking about this in the first place. They both came out in 1994, and they couldn’t be more different. One brought us the story of a real cowboy and professional bull rider. The other gave us Pepper and Sonny, two fictional New Mexico cowboys who end up running around New York City trying to find their friend.
And yet Hollywood looked at both stories and said:
Yep. Put them on the big screen.
So when did that stop happening so often?
Wait. Were There TOO MANY Cowboys?
This may be my favorite thing I learned while researching this article.
By the summer of 1994, Hollywood had somehow created the exact opposite of the problem I’m complaining about now.
There were too many cowboy movies.
When Wyatt Earp opened in June, a contemporary UPI box-office report called it the eighth Western released in just nine months and actually mentioned the “glut of cowboy films” it was competing against. Yes, apparently a cowboy glut was a real problem in 1994.
A glut.
Of cowboys.
Imagine having that problem.
I would like to experience this terrible hardship personally before forming an opinion.
The problem for Hollywood was that not all those movies were making money. Maverick did well. Others struggled. Wyatt Earp, which wasn’t exactly a cheap little movie someone filmed behind the barn, opened badly compared with its reported budget. The Los Angeles Times pointed out at the time that the success of Maverick and trouble for Wyatt Earp meant you couldn’t simply say audiences were tired of Westerns—things like tone, stars and the individual movie still mattered. Their 1994 box-office analysis is worth reading.
Still, Hollywood has never exactly been known for calmly assessing a situation.
Something makes money?
MAKE 47 MORE.
Several of those don’t make enough money?
ABORT. EVERYBODY OFF THE HORSES.
And maybe the cowboy comeback burned so brightly for a few years that Hollywood helped burn it out.
But I’m Not Really Asking Where the Western Went
This is where I realized I’d been asking the wrong question.
The Western never disappeared. Some incredible Westerns came after the ’90s, and the genre changed. It got darker in places. More revisionist. More interested in examining the mythology of the American West instead of simply celebrating it.
There’s nothing wrong with that. Some of those movies are fantastic.
But they’re not exactly what I’ve been missing.
I’m not sitting around thinking, Why won’t somebody give me another bleak examination of masculinity against an unforgiving American landscape?
I mean…maybe sometimes.
But mostly?
Where’s the damn cowboy movie?
Where’s the rodeo movie? Where’s the ranch movie? Where’s the cowboy buddy comedy? Where’s the romance where the guy happens to work a ranch? Where’s the movie where somebody can just be a cowboy without Hollywood needing to interrogate what the American West represents for the next two and a half hours?
Sometimes I just want the guy to be a cowboy.
That’s what movies like The Cowboy Way could do. Pepper and Sonny being cowboys is important to who they are, but the movie is a buddy adventure.
City Slickers could take a bunch of guys having midlife crises and put them on a cattle drive.
Pure Country could build a romance and drama around country music, ranch life and a man trying to figure out who he was underneath all the fame.
And 8 Seconds believed movie audiences would care about the real life of a professional bull rider.
Completely different stories.
There was room for all of them.
That’s what I miss.
The Cowboys Are Still Here
Here’s where things get interesting, because while I was asking where all the cowboys went at the movies, there was a pretty obvious answer sitting on my television.
They didn’t disappear.
A whole bunch of them moved to TV.
I’ve watched Heartland for years, and what I love about it isn’t constant insanity. I grew up with Amy. I grew up with her family and her horses. I watched their lives change.
The ranch isn’t some pretty background we’re visiting for two hours. It’s home.
Sometimes Amy is helping a horse. Sometimes the family is dealing with something huge. Sometimes they’re just living.
And you know what?
That’s enough.
CBC describes Heartland as the longest-running one-hour drama in Canadian television history, built around Amy Fleming and generations of her family living and working on their Alberta ranch. CBC has more about the series and its remarkable run here.
That’s what television can give this kind of story that a movie can’t.
Time.
We don’t just get a story about the ranch.
We get to live there with them.
Then there’s Yellowstone, which takes the ranch-family idea and turns the crazy dial approximately 9,000 percent higher.
The Duttons have land wars, murder, politics, family trauma and approximately twelve thousand other problems before breakfast.
Heartland it is not. 😂
But the ranch is still home. The cowboys aren’t decorations. The land matters. The horses matter. The work matters. The lifestyle matters.
And television gives all of it room to breathe. The New Yorker, writing about Yellowstone and the expansion of its universe, made an interesting point about television’s ability to spend time in the spaces a traditional Western movie often can’t. Their piece on Yellowstone and the Western on television is here.
A movie has a couple of hours.
Television can give us years. It can let a kid grow up. It can let a family change. It can let us learn the horses’ names. It can let a ranch become somewhere we recognize.
Movies give us a cowboy story.
Television lets us stay on the ranch.
And maybe that’s why cowboy stories found such a comfortable home there.
So Where Did the Hollywood Cowboy Go?
Turns out the answer isn’t as simple as I expected.
Hollywood didn’t stop making Westerns. Audiences didn’t suddenly stop caring about cowboys. And cowboy stories certainly didn’t die.
The ’90s really were a Western comeback, and I happened to grow up right in the middle of it. Then the theatrical boom cooled, the genre changed, studios became more cautious and television gave modern Western storytelling somewhere else to go.
So maybe the Hollywood cowboy didn’t completely ride off into the sunset.
Maybe he just changed addresses.
I’m glad he did.
I’m glad Heartland gave me years with Amy, her family and those horses. I’m glad television proved that people will still show up for ranches, rodeos, horses, cowboys and stories about people whose lives revolve around them.
But I’m going to be greedy here.
I want some of them back at the movies too.
Give me another rodeo movie. Give me another cowboy comedy. Give me another romance on a ranch. Give me another story where someone happens to be a cowboy and Hollywood doesn’t think that alone makes the movie old-fashioned.
And yes, keep making the serious Westerns too. There’s room for everybody.
Over the last few days, I’ve revisited two completely different cowboy stories from 1994. The Cowboy Way gave us Pepper and Sonny, two fictional cowboys dropped into one ridiculous adventure. 8 Seconds gave movie audiences the privilege of learning about Lane Frost, a real cowboy whose life and legacy deserved to be remembered.
Somewhere between revisiting those two movies, I started wondering why stories like these don’t seem to reach the big screen nearly as often anymore.
Turns out I wasn’t imagining things.
The cowboys really were everywhere for a while.
Hell, apparently there were so many of them in 1994 that Hollywood briefly considered it a problem.
Thirty-two years later?
I’m willing to take a few of them off your hands.
1994, if you’re listening, you don’t need to send everybody. Just give us a few of our cowboys back.
