I’ve always been a sucker for those old gangster movies. I don’t know what it is about them, but give me organized crime, questionable loyalties, and a bunch of people making really terrible decisions, and I’m probably going to enjoy myself. Which brings me to Road to Perdition (2002).
I loved this movie from the beginning. Yes, it’s a slow burn, but sometimes that’s exactly what a movie needs. Not everything has to move at a hundred miles an hour. Sometimes I want a movie to take its time and let me actually get to know the people I’m watching.
And good Lord, would you look at this cast! Tom Hanks, Paul Newman, Jude Law, Daniel Craig, Stanley Tucci, and a very young Tyler Hoechlin.
Yes, THAT Tyler Hoechlin. Our future werewolf, Superman, and certified heartthrob. But we’ll get to him because I have some things to say about that young man’s performance.
Spoiler Warning: We’re discussing major plot points, including the ending.
Paul Newman and One Hell of a Family Problem
First of all, Paul Newman. What a performance to give us in his final live-action feature film.
Newman plays John Rooney, an Irish mob boss who practically raised Michael Sullivan Sr. (Tom Hanks), one of his most trusted enforcers. Rooney also has a biological son, Connor, played by Daniel Craig. And Connor is arrogant, reckless, and apparently determined to make the worst decisions imaginable.
When Michael’s oldest son witnesses Connor commit a murder, Connor decides to eliminate anyone who might pose a threat to him. Unfortunately, that includes Michael’s family.
Connor’s actions result in the murders of Michael’s wife and younger son, Peter, leaving Michael Sr. and Michael Jr. with absolutely nothing except each other.
And John Rooney is furious.
You can tell he has absolutely had it with his son’s stupidity. What Connor did to Michael’s family is unforgivable, and Rooney knows it. He’s furious. He’s disgusted. And Newman doesn’t need some big dramatic outburst to make us see any of that.
But there’s a scene between Rooney and Michael Sr. that I absolutely love.
These two men know exactly what’s happening. Michael isn’t going to let what happened to his family go unanswered, and Rooney knows his son deserves whatever is coming.
But Rooney is still going to protect Connor.
And Michael understands why.
Because he’s doing the same damn thing for his own son.
That’s what makes that conversation so powerful. Two men who have spent their lives doing terrible things, looking each other in the eye and acknowledging that neither is going to stop protecting his child. And neither man needs the other to explain himself.
Paul Newman was incredible. What a way to finish a live-action film career.
Excuse Me, Is That Derek Hale?
Now, Tyler Hoechlin. I need to talk about Tyler Hoechlin.
Because before he was running around Beacon Hills as Derek Hale in Teen Wolf, before he put on Superman’s cape in Superman & Lois, and before he became quite the handsome man, he was Michael Sullivan Jr.
And holy hell, was that kid good.
He was surrounded by actors like Tom Hanks and Paul Newman, and not only did he hold his own, he gave us a performance that I still remember more than two decades later.
I can still picture his face. The agony, the terror, the happiness, the determination. Every emotion was right there. And I can still hear the confusion in his voice when his father was trying to teach him how to rob banks.
I mean, can you imagine? You’ve just been through absolute hell, you’re on the run with your father, and now Dad’s giving you lessons in bank robbery.
Those scenes still make me smile because they’re such a strange little bright spot in an otherwise heartbreaking movie. And Tyler handled them beautifully.
But what really impressed me was that he never felt like a child actor simply keeping up with the adults.
He made Michael Jr. real.
That’s what sticks with me. Not just that he went on to have a successful career. Not just that he became a werewolf and Superman. Although, seriously, good for him.
It’s that I can still remember the little boy he played and exactly how he made me feel.
That’s some serious acting chops right there.
Sometimes It Takes Losing Everything
One of the things I loved most about this movie was watching Michael Sr. and Michael Jr. finally get to know each other. Because they really weren’t that close in the beginning.
Michael Sr., played by Tom Hanks, isn’t exactly the warmest father in the world. He’s intimidating, distant, and not particularly good at showing affection. And I remember feeling like Michael Jr. didn’t think his father liked him very much.
There’s actually a conversation where Michael Jr. asks whether his father loved his younger brother Peter more than him.
Can you imagine being a child and feeling like you need to ask your father that?
Michael Sr. explains that Peter was sweet, but Michael Jr. reminded him of himself. And he didn’t want that. He didn’t want his son becoming the kind of man he’d become.
I thought that was incredibly sad. Here’s this little boy thinking his father doesn’t care for him the same way, when his father is actually terrified of what his son might become.
Then everything goes to hell. And suddenly they’re running for their lives together.
But something happens during that journey that I absolutely loved.
They start getting to know each other.
Not just as father and son who happen to live in the same house, but as two people who are finally allowing themselves to be vulnerable.
We see Michael Sr. become more loving and caring. We see Michael Jr. begin to understand his father. And we get these wonderful little moments when they can actually laugh together. Like those bank robberies.
I loved that they could find happiness together despite everything that had happened. And I loved watching Michael Sr. become the father Michael Jr. had probably wanted him to be all along.
Which, of course, makes what happens next hurt even more.
Jude Law, What in the Hell?
Okay, but can we discuss Jude Law for a minute?
Because that man was CREEPY.
He plays Harlen Maguire, a crime-scene photographer who also happens to be a hitman.
First of all, photographing dead bodies is already a creepy job. I understand somebody has to do it, but of course THIS particular photographer also happens to kill people.
And Jude Law was terrifying!
Everything about Maguire made my skin crawl. And he wasn’t playing around, either. That man had a job to do, and by God, he was determined to finish it.
Even at the very end, when you think Michael Sr. and Michael Jr. might finally be okay, there he is.
And before Michael Sr. can finish him off, Maguire manages to do exactly what he came there to do.
Jude Law was absolutely incredible in this film. He made that character genuinely frightening, and I loved every minute of his performance.
And Then They Broke My Heart
You know those movies where you spend the entire time hoping things are finally going to work out?
That’s how I felt watching Road to Perdition.
After everything Michael Sr. and Michael Jr. went through, after watching them finally become close, I just wanted them to be okay. They’d already lost so much.
And then, just when it seems like they’re finally going to have a little peace, Michael Sr. is killed. And Michael Jr. is left without his father.
That ending absolutely broke my heart.
But here’s what I love about it.
Michael Jr. never takes a life.
Despite everything he’s witnessed. Despite everything that’s been taken from him. Despite having every reason in the world to want revenge.
He never becomes a killer.
And that’s because of his father.
Michael Sr. spent his life killing people. He knew exactly what kind of man he was, and the last thing he wanted was for his son to follow in his footsteps.
He couldn’t save himself, but he made damn sure his son wouldn’t become him.
And I think that’s what makes the ending so powerful. Michael Jr. loses his father, but he doesn’t lose his innocence.
Thanks to the very man he once thought didn’t particularly like him.
And THAT is why Road to Perdition has stayed with me all these years. Not because it had an incredible cast, although it absolutely did. Not because I love old gangster movies, although I certainly do.
But because underneath all that crime, violence, and betrayal was a father and son who finally got to know and love each other the way they should have been able to all along.
And Tyler Hoechlin made sure we’d never forget that little boy.
What a movie.
